Tesla FSD Files Withheld by Bulgaria After France Demanded Confidentiality

Elon Musk at Tesla's GigaBerlin
Credit: Tesla

French authorities told other European Union regulators that all their correspondence on Tesla‘s Full Self-Driving (Supervised) system should be kept confidential, according to a Bulgarian government decision refusing to release the documents.

Bulgaria’s vehicle regulator, the Executive Agency Automobile Administration, cited the French request when it turned down a freedom-of-information application for the correspondence on November 13, according to the decision, which was shared on X on Wednesday by the user ‘FSDEurope’.

“Not least, in the course of the communication carried out, the French competent authorities explicitly stated that all correspondence regarding the Tesla Full Self-Driving (Supervised) system should be treated as confidential and not be publicly distributed,” the agency wrote, according to EV‘s translation of the Bulgarian text.

The decision is the first document to show France asking for secrecy over its position on the software, which the European Commission’s Technical Committee on Motor Vehicles is due to vote on before it can be approved across the bloc.

France has been the most outspoken large member state on the system.

Transport Minister Philippe Tabarot said in July that the government considered “the safety trade-offs are not yet sufficient to authorize it as it currently stands,” citing speeding behavior and insufficient driver monitoring.

In the same statement, published on the government’s Agora platform, Tabarot said “several other European countries share these reservations” and that France’s position “is therefore not isolated.” He said France was continuing “technical exchanges with the Netherlands and the other European states and Tesla.”

Musk replied on X that day: “Delaying the approval of FSD in France will cost lives.” It remains his only direct public comment on France’s stance.

His tone shifted after a video call with Tesla CEO Elon Musk on September 2. French authorities had been “working closely with Tesla on the technical adaptations that will enable France to support its approval,” Tabarot wrote on X, adding that Tesla was providing two FSD-equipped cars for road tests.

Musk answered Tabarot’s post with a heart and a French flag.

A Transport Ministry source told Reuters at the time that a vote could take place on October 6 or at the committee’s next meeting in early December, and that the ministry hoped to find “the right compromise” with Tesla “so that it goes in a positive direction,” according to a French-language version of the report.

France’s Ministry for the Ecological Transition has also refused to release its own documents. In August it turned down a request filed on the Ma Dada transparency platform, saying the Dutch application was “still being examined by the competent French authorities” and the documents were preparatory to an administrative decision.

The requester referred the refusal to France’s access-to-documents commission, CADA, on October 3. The ministry rejected a separate request on the same grounds on November 5.

Speed has been the main objection raised by European regulators. The RDW approved changes on November 3 that cut the margin by which the software may exceed speed limits to 10% from 50%, and renamed it Tesla Assisted Driving in Europe.

Sweden told the committee in April that it would vote against the system unless Tesla removed the function that lets it exceed speed limits.

What the Decision Says

The application, filed on November 2, sought the correspondence of French state bodies about Tesla FSD (Supervised) from January 1 to October 31, 2026, according to the decision.

The agency refused in full. It said the documents contained preliminary positions, proposals, objections and assessments exchanged between member states and the Commission, and that releasing them could lead to the “premature public disclosure of approaches that have not been finally formed and agreed.”

It also pointed to the French request directly. “Providing access to this information despite the explicitly stated requirement for confidentiality would affect the trust between the institutions involved and lead to a limitation of the future exchange of preliminary positions, assessments and opinions,” the agency said.

The decision cites Bulgaria’s Access to Public Information Act, the committee’s rules of procedure, which treat documents given to members as confidential under the EU treaties, and Bulgaria’s trade secrets law.

It concludes that the “explicit request of the French administrative authorities for confidentiality” was one of the grounds for refusal.

The agency classed the documents as official information that may be withheld when it contains “opinions and positions in connection with ongoing or forthcoming negotiations.” Citing the French request, it also applied the trade secrets law, saying the information requested was not public or readily accessible to people who usually handle such material.

Releasing it “would lead to significant consequences both at the institutional level and with regard to competitors in the market,” the agency wrote. It added that obtaining details about “the companies indicated in the request” could expose opportunities for abuse and unfair commercial practices, causing serious economic harm to the parties affected.

The agency also weighed whether an overriding public interest required disclosure. It acknowledged that driver-assistance systems are of public significance because they affect road safety, the technical compliance of vehicles and the actions of state authorities.

But it drew a line between the public’s interest in authorities’ final positions and the release of “the entire preliminary working correspondence” from a process still under way, and concluded that no overriding public interest applied.

It described the exchanges as part of a process in which member states and the Commission discuss the technical, legal and regulatory aspects of applying EU approval rules, including the conditions for the system’s use and each country’s approach.

The decision, marked TLP-GREEN and signed by the agency’s Executive Director, Boyko Ranovski, can be appealed to an administrative court within 14 days.

It also restates the legal path for the software.

The Dutch vehicle authority RDW issued a provisional EU type-approval on April 10 under Article 39(2) of Regulation (EU) 2018/858, valid only in the Netherlands, and the Commission is expected to adopt an implementing act for the whole bloc after the committee gives its opinion.

The Account’s Wider Claims

The documents do not reveal what France told other governments.

The account that published them said a source inside an EU member state had told it that France emailed all member states arguing the software did not meet certain regulatory requirements, raised speed-related concerns and urged them to vote against approval.

The account said itself that the emails remain undisclosed and that this claim has not been independently verified. EV has not seen the correspondence.

The account also said Bulgaria’s Transport Ministry had told it that it held no correspondence with French authorities on the matter. That reply was not among the documents posted.

Bulgaria’s public-information platform shows that the ministry ruled on November 17 on a November 2 request from an individual for its documents on communication between French and Bulgarian authorities about the system, and recorded that it granted “full access to the requested public information.”

The platform does not show what was released or who filed the request.

In a follow-up post, the account said it had sent requests to most member states and that all had either refused or said they had no communication with France, “until Bulgaria slipped.”

Bulgaria’s Own Position

The same account posted on Monday an August 11 report from Ranovski to Transport Minister Georgi Peev.

It said Tesla had applied on April 13 for Bulgaria to recognize the Dutch approval, and that an inter-ministerial meeting on July 10 concluded that the system offers technological improvements but in its current form “creates certain risks for road safety.”

The report said the system can decide to drive at 70 km/h instead of the permitted 50 km/h if surrounding traffic is moving faster, “without an explicit request from the driver,” and can exceed limits “by up to 50%.”

It also said the system “cannot guarantee optimal recognition of potholes and road unevenness,” which would pose the greatest risk given the poor state of Bulgaria’s roads.

Ranovski wrote that the agency “does not plan to recognize” the Dutch approval “until a common solution is found at European Union level.” Part of the report is blacked out in the published images.

Secrecy Elsewhere

Other regulators have also cited confidentiality. Denmark’s road traffic authority, which has recognized the Dutch approval, said in May that its type-approval work is subject to national and EU confidentiality duties, including its “participation and any votes in committees set up under the European Commission, including TCMV.”

The Danish agency said it receives “a large number” of inquiries and access requests on whether it is handling an application from Tesla.

The Count Ahead of a Vote

Finland on November 11 became the 11th EU country to allow the system on the basis of the Dutch approval. None of the bloc’s four most populous members, Germany, France, Italy and Spain, has recognized it, although Italy said in October it would back it at EU level.

EU-wide approval needs a qualified majority in the committee, meaning at least 15 of the 27 member states representing at least 65% of the bloc’s population. The committee has discussed the Dutch request three times without voting, most recently on October 6. Germany’s Transport Ministry has said a vote is planned for December.

Sweden’s Infrastructure Minister Andreas Carlson later said in a written parliamentary answer dated August 31 that the government’s “starting point and ambition” is an EU-wide approval of advanced driver-assistance systems such as Tesla FSD (Supervised), and that the committee was weighing extensive material, including the Swedish Transport Administration’s assessments.

Musk told Tesla’s third-quarter earnings call on October 21 that he hoped for EU-wide approval. “It’s hard to predict, but maybe within a few months,” he said. “I would be surprised if it takes longer than Q1.”

Musk in China

The disclosure comes as Musk travels in China. “I will be in China, so it will be digital me,” he wrote on X on Monday, explaining that he would attend The New York Times‘ DealBook Summit remotely.

The Associated Press reported that Trump was bringing Musk to the APEC summit in Shenzhen, citing administration officials, and Chinese media reported he arrived in the city with Trump’s motorcade on Wednesday.

Musk has not disclosed his itinerary or any meetings. Chinese outlets and social media users have framed the trip as a chance to push for full FSD approval in China, but neither Tesla nor Chinese authorities have linked the visit to the software.

Tesla has not yet won full approval there.

“We’re working very diligently to try and get broader — I mean, FSD approval in China. It is hard, but for certain cars, we have been able to have FSD operating,” Chief Financial Officer Vaibhav Taneja said on the October call. “We’re actively working with the regulators in China.”

France’s population share makes its vote important for any qualified majority.

Next on Tesla

Tesla Cybercab Wireless ChargingTesla Secures USPTO Review of 4 ChargeLogic EV Charging PatentsTesla has won a U.S. Patent and Trademark Office review of four of the six electric vehicle charging patents that a Texas patent-licensing company is asserting against it in…6h ago
Cláudio Afonso
Cláudio Afonso is the Founder and Editor of EV, an independent electric vehicle news publication owned by CARBA Investments, the company he founded in early 2021. Between 2022 and 2024 he worked in European corporate communications at Nio, and he returned to lead EV in April 2024. He is based in Portugal.