BYD Ti7 Banned From EU After Court Finds It Infringes Defender Design

BYD Ti7
Credit: BYD

BYD has been barred from selling, importing or building its Ti7 SUV anywhere in the European Union after a Dutch judge provisionally found that it infringes a registered EU design for Jaguar Land Rover‘s (JLR) Land Rover Defender, according to a ruling published by the District Court of The Hague on Friday.

The decision is the first ruling on whether the Ti7 infringes JLR’s Defender designs, and it comes nine days after the same court ordered JLR to destroy the BYD records it had seized in August.

“We strongly disagree with today’s judgment and will appeal it,” BYD said in a statement.

What the Judge Found

Preliminary relief judge J.B.J. Hoefnagel compared the Ti7 with the first of six EU designs JLR has registered for the current Defender, which JLR filed on April 25, 2018, more than a year before the model was introduced on September 10, 2019.

That design is characterized by “the bulging shoulders and the rounded corners, the signature panel, the cut-out of the wheel arches in rounded corners, the continuous window line, the proportions and (therefore) the overall silhouette,” the judge wrote in the Dutch-language ruling.

“If a comparison is made with the Ti7, in which these dominant and distinctive features are (nearly) identical to EU Design 1, it is above all the similarities that stand out,” the ruling said.

BYD did not dispute the similarities JLR pointed to, according to the ruling. It instead listed differences in the headlights, grille, bumpers, a recessed hood, a dark A-pillar, the missing “alpine windows,” the wheel arches, the rear lights and an enclosed spare wheel.

The judge found that the differences, “although many in number,” were “separately and taken together, not striking enough to significantly affect the overall impression” on an informed user.

Quotes from the ruling are translated from Dutch.

The ‘Defender DNA’ Defense

It was undisputed that some of the features JLR relies on are partly functional or part of the “Defender DNA” that has run through Defender generations since 1948, the judge noted.

The boxy outline, upright windows, straight roofline and high shoulder line already appear in older designs, the ruling said. The court used the Ford Flex, Jeep Wrangler and Mercedes G-Class as the main earlier designs for comparison.

The judge found that the specific combination in JLR’s design does not appear in those earlier vehicles, and that “the differences between EU Design 1 and the Ti7 are smaller than the differences between EU Design 1 and the design heritage.”

Because it found that the Ti7 infringes the first design, the court did not rule on BYD’s challenge to the validity of the other five designs.

Ten BYD Units, Including Hungary

The injunction covers 10 BYD companies, among them BYD Europe, BYD Nederland, and BYD’s units in France, Sweden, Denmark, Germany, Poland and Italy.

It also covers BYD Auto Hungary, which is to run BYD’s car factory in Szeged that aims to produce cars from the end of 2026, according to the ruling.

“If BYD brings the Ti7 to market in the EU, it is not inconceivable that these vehicles will be produced by BYD Hungary,” the judge wrote. If the Hungarian unit does not build the Ti7, “it will suffer no hindrance from this order,” the ruling said.

The companies must stop importing, producing, offering, selling, storing, delivering or otherwise trading the Ti7 in the EU within a week of being formally served with the judgment.

Each company that breaches the order faces a penalty of €100,000 ($109,900) for each day or part of a day, up to a total of €10 million ($11 million).

Why the Court Acted Before EU Sales

BYD argued there was no urgency, because the Ti7 can be ordered only from British dealers and it has “no concrete plans at the moment” to sell it in the EU, the ruling said.

The judge accepted that the Ti7 cannot currently be ordered in the EU, but found JLR had shown a threatened infringement there.

The court cited BYD’s U.K. launch, its statement that the Ti7 was developed for the U.K. and Europe, and two undated promotional videos. One was shown on the YouTube channels of BYD Europe and BYD France and on BYD Nederland’s Instagram account.

In the other, which features a left-hand-drive Ti7, a top BYD executive says: “The Ti7 finally arrived in UK. (…) So this is the first 7 seats SUV in Europe, in UK, in Europe,” according to the ruling.

The judge also took into account that BYD “has not undertaken not to bring the Ti7 to market in the EU in the foreseeable future.”

The U.K. Is Not Covered

The court declared itself without jurisdiction over BYD (U.K.) Co., which offers and promotes the Ti7 in Britain.

The British unit is not a subsidiary of BYD Europe, and it “could not reasonably be expected” to have to appear before a Dutch court over alleged infringements in the U.K., the judge wrote.

The court also rejected JLR’s claims under its U.K. designs against the Dutch BYD companies. JLR had not shown that BYD Europe was responsible for the British unit’s website, and a mention of BYD Europe in general information at the bottom of the site was not enough, the ruling said.

JLR plans to sue BYD in Britain, The Times reported. JLR has not said so publicly.

BYD’s U.K. website lists the Ti7 from £47,995 ($63,000) on the road. BYD said in July that customers could expect first deliveries in January 2027.

Land Rover’s U.K. website lists the Defender 110 from £64,315 ($84,400).

What JLR Did Not Get

The judge turned down JLR’s request for access to the documents seized from BYD in August, saying its interests are “sufficiently served” by the injunction for now.

The court also rejected JLR’s demands for data on the Ti7’s distribution channels, profits and stock, and for a notice on all of BYD’s European websites saying the Ti7 had been “withdrawn from sale with immediate effect.”

The judge criticized how JLR presented its case. The design images it filed were “very small,” it submitted only six of the seven images of each design, and parts of the registrations it filed had disappeared “under the cookie notice,” the ruling said.

JLR gave a clearer explanation of its claims only at the November 3 hearing, the judge noted. The court still found that BYD knew what it had to defend against and was not unfairly harmed.

Lawyers of the Chinese giant had first filed a 131-page defense, which the judge refused for its length before accepting a replacement of no more than 70 pages filed the same day.

BYD’s companies, excluding the British unit, must pay €2,700 ($3,000) in costs. JLR had claimed €55,200 ($60,700) in lawyers’ fees, but the judge found them insufficiently itemized because its breakdown ran only to August 26.

What the Companies Said

“We protect our intellectual property and take legal action when necessary,” JLR said in a statement. “Legal proceedings are ongoing, and we won’t be commenting further at this time.”

“The BYD Ti 7 is the result of BYD’s own independent design work and infringes none of JLR’s rights,” BYD said. “We will pursue every legal avenue to demonstrate that this decision is incorrect.”

A Provisional Ruling

The decision was made in summary proceedings, which give a provisional ruling until a court decides the full case.

JLR must start full proceedings within six months of the ruling, or the ban may lose its force, the court said in a statement.

The ruling is provisionally enforceable, meaning it applies while any appeal is pending.

How the Case Got Here

JLR sued BYD in The Hague with a summons dated September 4, according to the ruling.

Before that, the court had on August 14 allowed JLR to seize BYD records on the basis of its EU designs, while refusing to do so on the basis of its U.K. designs. Bailiffs carried out the seizure on August 24 at BYD offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp.

The Sunday Times made the searches public on November 8.

On November 11, a different judge at the same court lifted that seizure in a case BYD brought, finding JLR had not shown it needed the records because the Ti7 had not been sold in the EU. The court published a corrected version the next day.

In China, the Ti7 is sold by BYD’s off-road Fangchengbao brand, which launched it on September 9, 2025, according to the ruling.

JLR retailed 29,500 Defenders in the July-to-September quarter, up 16.3% from a year earlier, the company said in October.

JLR is pursuing a separate summary case against BYD at the District Court of Rotterdam, alleging copyright infringement and slavish imitation of the Defender.

The oral hearing in that case is scheduled for November 25, according to the Hague ruling.

Next on BYD

BYD Atto 2BYD Got Nvidia H200 License as Nio and Geely Bids Stayed Pending, Files ShowThe U.S. Commerce Department approved an Nvidia license to supply 4,000 H200 artificial intelligence chips to BYD, while applications Nvidia filed for rivals Nio and Geely were still awaiting a decision as of May 11,…Yesterday
Cláudio Afonso
Cláudio Afonso is the Founder and Editor of EV, an independent electric vehicle news publication owned by CARBA Investments, the company he founded in early 2021. Between 2022 and 2024 he worked in European corporate communications at Nio, and he returned to lead EV in April 2024. He is based in Portugal.